Blue Gate BakeryShipshewana, Indiana
View product
bluegatebakery Amish Peanut Butter Spread
$5.99
Baked Freshin Shipshewana
What Are You Craving?
From the bakery case to your kitchen.
A Little Taste of Shipshewana
Homemade Still Means Something Here.
At the Blue Gate Bakery, we're still baking the kind of food people make a special trip to Shipshewana to find. Fresh pies, breads, cinnamon rolls, cookies and other favorites come out of our bakery six days a week.
And you don't have to be in Shipshewana to enjoy them. We carefully pack and ship many of our Blue Gate favorites so you can bring a little taste of Amish Country home.
Custom Cakes & Cookies
From birthdays and weddings to special events and corporate gifts, we’ll create something as special as the moment you’re celebrating.
Made From Scratch
Quality ingredients and time-honored recipes.
Custom Designed
Your vision, our attention to detail.
Made To Order
Each order is baked fresh for your event.
Pickup Options
Convenient pickup for your celebration.
From Our Bakery to Your Door
Shipshewana is closer than you think.
We carefully bake, pack and ship Blue Gate favorites across the country, so a little taste of Shipshewana can arrive right at your door.
Shop Shippable Favorites →
We bake it.
Your Blue Gate favorites are prepared right here in Shipshewana.
We pack it.
Bakery items are carefully packaged at our store.
You enjoy it.
We ship across the country, with most shipments allowing approximately 3–5 business days.
What Our Customers Are Saying
From Our Bakery to Your Table
Thank you for making us a part of your tradition.
★★★★★
“Blue Gate Bakery is a must when we visit Shipshewana, and I am so glad we can get our favorites at home too!”
— Jennifer L. — Phoenix, AZ
★★★★★
“Everything was packed so carefully and arrived in perfect condition. You can tell they take pride in what they do.”
— Melissa P. — Nashville, TN
★★★★★
“We order pies for every holiday. The Dutch Apple is our favorite. It tastes just like home.”
— Tom & Sandy R. — Grand Rapids, MI
★★★★★
“The cinnamon rolls are absolutely the best! They arrived fresh and were gone in minutes.”
— Karen M. — Louisville, KY
